Back to Blog

Choosing the Right Solicitor for Your New Build: CQS Accreditation, Fee Structures Compared, Panel vs Independent, Questions to Ask Before Instructing, Red Flags, and How to Switch Mid-Transaction

Choosing the Right Solicitor for Your New Build: CQS Accreditation, Fee Structures Compared, Panel vs Independent, Questions to Ask Before Instructing, Red Flags, and How to Switch Mid-Transaction
Free PDF available for this topicDownload Solicitor Instruction Checklist

Types of Conveyancing Providers

In England and Wales, three types of legal professionals can handle your new build conveyancing.

ProviderQualificationRegulated ByTypical FirmsNew Build Suitability
SolicitorLaw degree + LPC + 2-year training contract (or SQE route)Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA)High street law firms, specialist conveyancing firms, national firmsExcellent — if they have specific new build experience
Licensed conveyancerCLC conveyancing qualification — specialist property qualificationCouncil for Licensed Conveyancers (CLC)Specialist conveyancing firms, online conveyancersExcellent — dedicated property specialists. Many handle high volumes of new builds
Chartered Legal Executive (CILEx)CILEx qualifications in property lawCILEx RegulationUsually work within solicitor firmsGood — if authorised for conveyancing and experienced with new builds

The type of qualification matters less than the individual's experience with new build transactions. A licensed conveyancer who handles 50 new build purchases a year will outperform a solicitor who handles 2.

CQS Accreditation Explained

The Conveyancing Quality Scheme (CQS) is a quality standard operated by the Law Society. It is one of the most important indicators of conveyancing competence.

What CQS Means

AspectDetail
What it isA quality mark awarded to conveyancing practices that meet the Law Society's standards for competence, client service, and risk management
How it is awardedFirms must apply and demonstrate they meet defined standards. Annual renewal requires ongoing compliance
What it coversClient care, file management, anti-money-laundering compliance, professional indemnity insurance, staff training, complaints handling
Why it matters for youMany mortgage lenders require their panel solicitors to hold CQS accreditation. If your solicitor is not CQS accredited, your lender may not accept them
How to checkSearch the Law Society's CQS directory online. The firm's CQS status should be current, not lapsed

CQS and Lender Panels

Lender TypeCQS Requirement
Major high street lendersMost require CQS or equivalent. Check with your specific lender
Building societiesMany require CQS. Some have their own panel requirements
Specialist lendersRequirements vary. Some are more flexible, others more restrictive
Cash purchasesCQS is not required for cash purchases but remains a useful quality indicator

Developer Panel vs Independent Solicitor

This is one of the most important decisions you will make. The developer will almost certainly recommend a solicitor — should you use them?

Comparison

FactorDeveloper Panel SolicitorIndependent Solicitor
How you find themDeveloper recommends them at the sales officeYou research and choose them yourself
CostOften slightly cheaper — may be subsidised by the developer or offer discounted fees to win referralsStandard market rates. May be £200–£500 more
SpeedGenerally faster — familiar with the developer's contracts and processesMay be slightly slower initially but more thorough
Contract scrutinyLess likely to challenge the developer's contract aggressively — depends on the developer for future businessNo relationship with the developer — will review and challenge the contract purely in your interests
CommunicationVariable — some panel firms handle high volumes with less personal attentionVariable — depends on the firm. Independent does not automatically mean better service
Conflict of interestPotential conflict between your interests and maintaining the developer relationshipNo conflict — works exclusively for you
Familiarity with the developmentMay have acted on other plots on the same development — already familiar with title issues, planning, and managementStarts fresh — but this means a thorough independent review rather than assumptions based on previous plots
Lender panel membershipUsually on major lender panels (developers ensure this)Must check they are on your specific lender's panel

Recommendation

For most buyers, an independent solicitor with new build experience is the safer choice. The potential cost saving of a panel solicitor (£200–£500) is small relative to the purchase price and the risks of inadequate scrutiny. If you do choose the developer's recommended solicitor, verify they will review and challenge the contract on your behalf — not just rubber-stamp it.

Fee Structures Compared

Understanding how solicitors charge ensures you compare quotes fairly and avoid unexpected bills.

Fee Types

Fee TypeHow It WorksProsCons
Fixed feeAgreed total cost for the conveyancing work, regardless of how long it takesCertainty — you know the total cost upfront. No surprisesIf the transaction is complex, the firm may cut corners to stay within budget
Hourly rateCharged per hour of work. Typically £150–£350/hour depending on location and seniorityYou pay for the work actually done. Complex matters get the time they needNo cost certainty. Bills can escalate, especially with delays or complications
No sale, no feeYou only pay if the transaction completes. If it falls through, you pay nothing (or a reduced amount)Lower risk if the purchase does not proceedFirms absorb failed transaction costs across all clients — so the base fee is higher. May also incentivise the firm to push for completion even when you should withdraw
Percentage of purchase priceFee is a percentage of the property price (e.g., 0.5%). Uncommon for residential conveyancingSimple to calculateA more expensive property does not necessarily mean more legal work. You may overpay

What Should Be Included in a Quote

ItemShould Be in the QuoteWatch Out For
Basic conveyancing feeYes — the core fee for the conveyancing workCheck whether this includes the new build supplement or whether that is extra
New build supplementShould be stated separately or included in the basic feeSome firms charge £150–£350 extra for new builds. Check this is in the quote, not added later
Leasehold supplementShould be stated if your property is leasehold£200–£400 extra. If you are buying a flat, this will apply
VATAll fees should state whether they include or exclude VAT (20%)A quote of £1,000 + VAT is actually £1,200. Always compare VAT-inclusive figures
DisbursementsShould be listed — searches, Land Registry fees, bank transfer feesDisbursements are third-party costs that the solicitor pays on your behalf. They are not the solicitor's profit. Typical total: £300–£600
Bank transfer fees (CHAPS)Should be stated — typically £30–£50 per transferUsually 2–3 transfers needed (deposit, completion, SDLT payment). Some firms charge per transfer, others include all transfers
ID verificationShould be stated — £5–£20 per personJoint purchases (two buyers) pay twice
Stamp Duty filingShould be included in the basic fee or stated separatelySome firms charge £50–£100 extra for SDLT filing. This should be included

Typical Total Costs

Property TypeSolicitor Fee (inc. VAT)DisbursementsTotal
New build freehold house£1,200–£2,200£300–£550£1,500–£2,750
New build leasehold flat£1,500–£2,800£350–£600£1,850–£3,400
New build shared ownership£1,600–£3,000£350–£600£1,950–£3,600
New build off-plan (any type)Add £100–£300 for extended monitoringSameAdd £100–£300 to above

Essential Questions to Ask Before Instructing

These questions help you assess whether a solicitor is right for your new build purchase.

Experience Questions

QuestionGood AnswerRed Flag
How many new build purchases do you handle per year?20+ per year indicates regular experience'A few' or inability to give a number suggests limited experience
Have you handled purchases from this specific developer before?If yes, they know the developer's standard contract and common issues. If no, that is fine — they will review freshIf they say they handle all of the developer's transactions, consider the conflict of interest
Who will handle my file day-to-day?A named solicitor or licensed conveyancer with relevant experience'It depends on who is available' or 'our team handles it collectively' — you want a named contact
What is your experience with leasehold/shared ownership?If your purchase is leasehold or shared ownership, specific experience is importantHesitation or vague answers suggest limited experience with these more complex purchases

Service Questions

QuestionGood AnswerRed Flag
What is your average response time?Same working day for emails, 24 hours for complex queries'We try to respond within a week' is too slow for conveyancing where deadlines matter
Do you provide online case tracking?Many modern firms offer portals where you can see your case progressNot essential but useful. Lack of tracking means you rely entirely on the solicitor for updates
Will you review and challenge the developer's contract?'Yes, we review every clause and will raise concerns and attempt amendments where appropriate''Developer contracts are standard and don't change' — this suggests a rubber-stamping approach
How do you handle completion at short notice?'We prepare for completion in advance so we can act quickly when the developer gives notice''We need at least 4 weeks' notice' — if your contract only gives 10 days, this firm may not be able to meet the deadline

Fee Questions

QuestionGood AnswerRed Flag
Can you provide a full written quote including all fees and disbursements?Yes — a detailed breakdown with VAT and all anticipated disbursementsVague estimates, verbal-only quotes, or 'we will let you know as we go along'
Are there any circumstances where the fee could increase?Honest disclosure — 'if the transaction involves unexpected complexity, we would discuss additional costs with you first''No, the fee is fixed no matter what' combined with a suspiciously low quote may mean corners will be cut
What happens to fees if the purchase falls through?Clear policy — some firms charge nothing, others charge for work done, others charge a reduced 'abortive' feeNo clear policy or refusal to discuss it
Do you charge separately for the new build supplement?Either included in the quote or clearly stated as an additional amountNot mentioned and then added to the final bill

Red Flags When Choosing a Solicitor

Red FlagWhy It Is ConcerningWhat to Do
Significantly cheaper than competitorsIf a quote is £500+ below other quotes, the firm may be cutting corners, employing junior staff, or planning to add charges laterAsk what is included. Compare like-for-like. The cheapest option is rarely the best for a new build purchase
No named contact for your fileYour case may be passed between staff with no one taking ownership. Important details can be missed in handoversInsist on knowing who will handle your file and ask for their direct contact details
Slow initial responseIf they take days to respond to your initial enquiry, expect similar (or worse) during the transaction when time-critical actions are neededMove on. Response time during the enquiry stage is the best indicator of service quality
Cannot confirm lender panel membershipIf the solicitor is not on your lender's panel, they cannot act on the lender's behalf and you will need a second solicitor — adding cost and complicationConfirm panel membership with your specific lender before instructing. Provide your lender's name when getting quotes
No CQS accreditation (if required by your lender)Many lenders require CQS. Without it, you may need to find another solicitor mid-transactionCheck CQS status on the Law Society website. Confirm with your lender whether they require it
Pushes you to exchange without thorough reviewA solicitor who rushes you to exchange may be prioritising speed over protectionYour solicitor should never pressure you to exchange before they have completed their due diligence and you are comfortable
Dismisses your concernsIf you raise questions and the solicitor dismisses them as 'nothing to worry about' without explanation, they may not be taking your interests seriouslyA good solicitor explains why something is or is not a concern. Dismissal without explanation is unprofessional
Poor online reviews mentioning communicationConsistent complaints about lack of communication, missed deadlines, or difficulty reaching the solicitor indicate systemic problemsCheck Google reviews, Trustpilot, and the SRA/CLC websites for disciplinary actions. A few negative reviews are normal; a pattern is a warning

Online vs High Street Solicitors

FactorOnline / RemoteHigh Street / Local
CostOften cheaper due to lower overheadsUsually slightly more expensive
CommunicationEmail, phone, video calls. Some offer online portalsFace-to-face meetings available. Phone and email also
ConvenienceCan instruct from anywhere. No need to travelLocal presence. Can visit the office to sign documents or discuss concerns in person
AvailabilitySome offer extended hours or weekend availabilityUsually standard office hours (9am–5pm weekdays)
Local knowledgeMay not be familiar with your specific area or councilFamiliar with local planning, local authority search quirks, and area-specific issues
VolumeHigh-volume firms may process transactions efficiently but with less personal attentionLower volume may mean more personal attention but potentially slower
QualityVaries widely — excellent online firms exist alongside poor onesVaries widely — the same range of quality as online

Location matters less than quality and experience. A good online solicitor 200 miles away is better than a poor local solicitor. The key factors remain: new build experience, CQS accreditation (if required), lender panel membership, and communication quality.

The Lender Panel Requirement

If you are buying with a mortgage, your solicitor must be on your lender's panel to act on both your and the lender's behalf.

How Panels Work

AspectDetail
What it meansThe lender has approved the solicitor to act on their behalf in mortgage transactions. The solicitor certifies the property meets the lender's requirements
Why it mattersIf your solicitor is not on the panel, the lender will appoint a separate solicitor to act for them. You pay for both solicitors — doubling your costs
How to checkAsk the solicitor when you get a quote. Give them your lender's name and ask them to confirm they are on the panel. Most large firms are on all major lender panels
What if they are not on the panel?Either choose a different solicitor who is, or accept the cost of two solicitors (not recommended for cost reasons)
Changing lender mid-transactionIf you switch mortgage lender during the process, check your solicitor is on the new lender's panel. If not, you may need to change solicitor too

How to Switch Solicitors Mid-Transaction

Sometimes you need to change solicitors — poor communication, missed deadlines, or loss of confidence. While switching mid-transaction is disruptive, it is possible and sometimes necessary.

Step-by-Step Process

StepActionNotes
1. Instruct new solicitor firstFind and instruct your new solicitor before formally leaving the old one. Confirm they are on your lender's panel and can take overDo not leave yourself without legal representation during the transition
2. Notify old solicitor in writingSend a letter or email confirming you are withdrawing instructions and requesting a file transfer to your new solicitorProvide the new solicitor's name, address, and reference number
3. File transferOld solicitor must transfer the file (all documents, search results, correspondence) to the new solicitorUnder SRA rules, a solicitor cannot hold your file hostage. They must transfer it on request, subject to any lien for unpaid fees
4. Pay any outstanding feesYou may owe fees for work already done by the old solicitorIf on a fixed fee with a 'no completion, no fee' arrangement, check whether any fees are due. If on hourly rates, expect a bill for time spent
5. New solicitor reviews the fileYour new solicitor reviews everything done so far and picks up from where the old solicitor left offThey may need to re-do some work if they are not satisfied with the quality. Search results can usually be transferred
6. Notify the developer's solicitorYour new solicitor contacts the developer's solicitor to take over the transactionThe developer's solicitor deals with whoever you instruct — they cannot refuse to work with your new solicitor
7. Notify your lenderYour new solicitor contacts your lender to take over as the lender's representativeMust be on the lender's panel. Lender may need to re-issue the mortgage offer addressed to the new solicitor

Costs and Delays

ImpactTypical Amount
Old solicitor's fees for work done£200–£800 depending on how far into the process you are
New solicitor's full feeTheir standard quote — you pay in full for a new instruction
Delay to transaction2–4 weeks for file transfer and review
Search re-useMost search results can be transferred and re-used if still within their validity period (typically 6 months)

When switching is worth it: If your solicitor is unresponsive, missing deadlines, or you have lost confidence in their ability to protect your interests, switching is better than proceeding with inadequate representation. The cost of switching (£400–£1,200 extra) is small compared to the cost of a botched conveyancing transaction.

Working Effectively with Your Solicitor

Your ResponsibilityDetail
Provide documents promptlyID, proof of address, proof of funds, mortgage details — send these within 24–48 hours of request. Every day of delay on your side is a day added to the process
Read their reportYour solicitor's report is the most important document you receive before exchange. Read every page. This is where they explain what they have found and flag risks
Ask questionsIf anything is unclear, ask. No question is too basic. A good solicitor explains complex legal concepts in plain English
Respond to queries promptlyWhen your solicitor asks you a question or needs a decision, respond quickly. Delays compound — a 3-day delay on your response can cause a 2-week delay in the process
Keep them informedTell your solicitor about any changes — new mortgage offer, change of circumstances, issues raised by the developer, anything agreed with the sales office
Do not bypass themDo not agree to contract changes, incentive modifications, or completion date adjustments directly with the developer or sales office. Everything should go through your solicitor
Be patient with searchesLocal authority searches can take 1–6 weeks depending on the council. Your solicitor cannot speed this up — it is entirely in the council's hands
Provide clear instructionsWhen asked to make a decision (e.g., proceed with a risk, accept a clause, fund a shortfall), give clear, written instructions

When Things Go Wrong — Complaints and Remedies

Internal Complaints

StepAction
1. Raise with your solicitor directlyPut your complaint in writing (email or letter). Explain what went wrong and what outcome you want
2. Ask for their complaints procedureAll regulated firms must have a written complaints procedure. They must provide it on request
3. Escalate to a senior partnerIf your day-to-day contact cannot resolve the issue, escalate to a partner or complaints handler within the firm
4. Allow time for responseThe firm has 8 weeks to respond to your complaint under SRA and CLC rules

External Complaints

BodyWhen to ContactWhat They Can Do
Legal OmbudsmanIf the firm has not resolved your complaint within 8 weeks, or you are unhappy with their response. Must complain within 1 year of the issueInvestigate complaints about service quality. Can order the firm to refund fees, pay compensation (up to £50,000), or take other action
Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA)For serious misconduct — dishonesty, misuse of client funds, discrimination, failure to act in your interestsInvestigate and discipline solicitors. Can issue fines, conditions, or strike the solicitor off the register
Council for Licensed Conveyancers (CLC)Same as SRA but for licensed conveyancersSame powers as SRA for their regulated professionals

Professional Negligence Claims

AspectDetail
What it isA legal claim against your solicitor for financial loss caused by their failure to meet professional standards
ExamplesFailed to identify a title defect, missed a search issue that caused you loss, failed to check the warranty was acceptable to your lender, miscalculated stamp duty
Time limitGenerally 6 years from the date of the negligent act (not from when you discovered the problem)
How it worksYou make a claim against the solicitor's professional indemnity insurance. All regulated solicitors must carry this insurance
What you need to proveThe solicitor owed you a duty of care, they breached that duty, and you suffered a financial loss as a result
CostPursuing a negligence claim requires specialist legal advice. Some solicitors offer no-win-no-fee arrangements for strong claims. Costs can be £5,000–£50,000+ depending on complexity

Checklist: Choosing Your Solicitor

ItemDone?
Get quotes from at least 3 firms
Confirm they have new build conveyancing experience (20+ transactions/year ideal)
Check CQS accreditation on Law Society website
Confirm they are on your mortgage lender's panel
Get a full written quote with all fees and disbursements (VAT inclusive)
Ask who will handle your file (named individual)
Ask about their response times and communication approach
Confirm they will review and challenge the developer's contract
Check online reviews for communication quality
Ask about their complaints procedure
Understand their policy if the purchase falls through
Confirm they can handle your specific purchase type (leasehold/shared ownership if applicable)

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I choose the cheapest solicitor?

No. Conveyancing fees for new builds typically range from £1,200–£3,000. The difference between the cheapest and a mid-range specialist might be £300–£500. For a purchase worth £200,000–£500,000, saving £300 on legal fees while getting less thorough scrutiny is a false economy. Compare value, not just price — experience, communication quality, and thoroughness matter more than the cheapest quote.

Does it matter if my solicitor is local?

Not significantly. Conveyancing is largely done remotely — searches are ordered online, communication is by email and phone, and documents can be signed electronically or posted. Local knowledge can be helpful for understanding specific council search quirks, but a good new build solicitor anywhere in England and Wales can handle your purchase effectively. Choose quality over proximity.

Can I switch solicitors after exchanging contracts?

Yes, but it is more disruptive and urgent post-exchange because you are legally committed with a completion deadline. The process is the same — instruct a new solicitor, transfer the file, notify the developer's solicitor and lender. Do it immediately if you have serious concerns about your solicitor's competence, as post-exchange errors can be extremely costly.

What if my solicitor and mortgage broker recommend different firms?

Your mortgage broker may recommend a solicitor because of a referral fee arrangement — they receive a commission for the referral. This is legal but must be disclosed. The same potential conflict exists as with developer panel solicitors. Consider the recommendation but make your own independent choice based on the criteria in this guide.

Do I need a different solicitor for Scotland?

Yes. Scottish property law is different from English law. You need a Scottish solicitor for purchases in Scotland. The conveyancing process, contract system (missives), and land registration (Registers of Scotland) are all different. This guide covers England and Wales — Scottish buyers should seek a solicitor experienced in Scottish new build conveyancing.

What is the difference between a solicitor and a conveyancer?

A solicitor is a fully qualified lawyer who can handle all legal matters, including conveyancing. A licensed conveyancer is a specialist property lawyer who only handles conveyancing. Both are regulated and insured. For new build conveyancing, either can be excellent — the key is new build experience. Licensed conveyancers who specialise in new builds may actually have more relevant experience than a general practice solicitor who handles conveyancing occasionally.

Property Assistant

Ask me anything